| Fish | Location | Size | Season | Rarity | Notes | Sam's Sell Price | Bastian's Sell Price |
| Mosquitofish | Mine | Small | All | Common | 50G | - | |
| Perch | Stream/Pond | Medium | All | Common | 119G | 170G | |
| Yellow Perch | Stream | Medium | All | Common | 119G | 170G | |
| Akame | Mine | Large | Fall | Rare | Night | 1,500G | |
| Goby | Pond/Mine | Fall | Rare | 150G | - | ||
| Barbatus | Pond | Small |
Spring Summer Fall |
Common | All Day | 105G | 150G |
| Bullhead | Mine | Large | Fall | Rare | 119G | 170G | |
| Rainbow Trout | Mine | Medium | Summer Fall | Uncommon | 350G | 500G | |
| Green Arowana | 7th tree expanded lake | Large | Summer | Rare | boat, rain/fog | 3,500G | 5,000G |
| Banjar Arowana | Large | ||||||
| Golden Arowana | Large | ||||||
| Super Red Arowana | Large | ||||||
| Bluegill | Mine | Medium | Fall | 84G | 120G | ||
| Crucian Carp | Mine | Medium | All | Uncommon | 100G | - | |
| White Crucian Carp | Mine | Medium | All | Common | 150G | - | |
| Goldfish | Mine
Stream |
Tiny | Spring
Fall |
Common | 3,000G | - | |
| Calico Goldfish | 2nd mine stream | Tiny | Winter | Rare | Land Glorious Rod | ||
| Alligator Gar | 11 blocks from shore (23x23) | Massive | Summer | Rare | Boat | 15,000G | |
| Spotted Gar | 11 blocks from shore (23x23) | Large | Summer Fall | Uncommon | Boat | 3,000G | |
| Black Bass | Pond | Large | Fall (best) | Uncommon | 100G | - | |
| Tilapia | Mine
Stream (waterfall before the pond) |
Medium | Summer | Uncommon | 105G | 150G | |
| Redbelly Tilapia | 3x3 Mine waterfall | Medium | Summer | Rare | after 1pm | 140G | 200G |
| Arapaima | 11 blocks from shore (23x23) | Massive | Summer | Rare | Glorious Rod | ||
| Piranha | 22x22 lake | Small |
Spring Summer Fall |
Boat | 105G | ||
| Piraya Piranha | 22x22 lake | Medium | Spring Fall | Uncommon | Boat | 140G | |
| Electric Eel | Low Artificial 1x10 | Massive | Summer |
Very Rare Glorious Rod (I recommend electric feed) |
Land |
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||